Where Every Flavor is PARADISE!

Try them all - we dare you!

When the spoon first hits your mouth...
you completely understand the urge to SCREAM for ICE CREAM!

(And go right ahead – we won’t judge!)

National Award-Winning Ice Cream

Thurgood Creamery’s ice cream has been recognized by the National Ice Cream Association! 

Our Strawberry and Heifer’s Revenge (chocolate) won prestigious awards, judged by Cornell University.

Come taste the excellence that has been celebrated on a national stage!

award winning ice cream - thurgood creamery

Year Round Favorites

Raspberry Cheesecake Crumble


Enjoy a sweet escape with Raspberry Cheesecake Crumble, a delightful mix of cheesecake ice cream, raspberry swirls, and crunchy graham cracker pieces.

Heifer's Revenge


Embrace the boldness of a rich chocolate ice cream base, chocolate fudge brownies, and caramel swirls for true chocolate aficionado.

Throttled Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Throttled Cookie Dough


Discover cookie heaven with Throttled Cookie Dough, loaded with goey cookie dough chunks and chocolate chip cookie pieces.

Honey Comb


Dive into the sweet, crunchy goodness of our Honey Comb ice cream, sweet cream base bursting with real honeycomb candy pieces in every bite.

Cookies N' Cream - Thurgood Creamery Ice Cream
Cookies N' Cream


A classic favorite, our Cookies N' Cream combines creamy white chocolate Ghirardelli ice cream with chunks of chocolate sandwich cookies for a perfect balance of flavors.

Chocolate Ice Cream
Classic Chocolate


Indulge in the rich, velvety goodness of our Classic Chocolate. Each bite is a heavenly blend of deep chocolate flavor and luxurious sweetness, perfect for satisfying your most intense chocolate cravings.

Mint Chip (GF)


Refresh your palate with Mint Chip, a cool mint-flavored ice cream speckled with dark chocolate chips and pieces of Andes mints candies.

Birthday Monster
Birthday Monster


Celebrate any day with our Birthday Cake base ice cream, a festive blend of cake-flavored ice cream, colorful sprinkles, and ribbons of frosting.

I-15 Pothole Rocky Road
I-15 Pothole "Rocky Road" (GF)


Embark on a wild ride with I-15 Pothole "Rocky Road", a thrilling mix of chocolate ice cream, marshmallows, and almonds.

Ooey Goey Butter Cake


Indulge in the sweet and buttery bliss of Ooey Gooey Butter Bake, a heavenly blend of rich butter cake pieces swirled in creamy sweet cream ice cream.

Syracuse Salted Caramel
Syracuse Salted Caramel (GF)


Savor the sweet and salty magic of Syracuse Salted Caramel, a delight of creamy caramel ice cream, rich caramel ribbons, and a touch of sea salt.

Double Fold Vanilla Ice Cream
Double Fold Vanilla (GF)


Indulge in the rich and aromatic glory of our Double Fold Vanilla, crafted with an extra helping of Madagascar vanilla for a truly luxurious treat.

ALLERGY FRIENDLY - Gluten Free, Dairy Free, and Vegan

Chocolate with Attitude
Brownie Batter (DF/GF/V)


Treat yourself to the richness of Brownie Batter Ice Cream - where every scoop tastes just like rich, chocolate, gooey, decadent flavor of brownie batter - perfect for chocolate lovers!

Coconut (DF/GF/V)


Experience the tropical escape of Coconut ice cream, where each scoop is packed with the rich and creamy essence of real coconuts. This treat delivers a silky texture and an explosion of exotic flavor.

Cookies & Cream (DF/GF/V)


Now in a dairy-free and gluten-free version that doesn't skimp on taste. Crunchy cookie bits swirled through creamy, smooth vanilla base offer a perfect balance of textures, making each spoonful a guilt-free indulgence.

Fresh Strawberry (DF/GF/V)


Bursting with the sweetness of ripe strawberries, each bite is loaded with real strawberry fruit pieces, enveloped in a creamy, allergy friendly base.

Mint Oreo (DF/GF/V)


Crunchy cookie bits swirled through creamy, smooth vanilla base offers a perfect balance of textures that makes each spoonful a minty chocolate indulgence.

Fresh Lemon Ice Cream
Fresh Lemon (DF/GF/V)


Fresh lemon ice cream is like a scoop of sunshine, zesty and refreshing. Its bright, tangy lemon flavor creates a light and invigorating treat that is perfect for whenever you need a little zest in your life.

Honey Roasted Macadamia Nut
Honey Roasted Macadamia Nut (DF/GF)


Indulge in the unique and luxurious taste of roasted macadamia nuts drizzled with a honey-like sweetness are mixed into a rich, creamy base that offers a crunchy, nutty experience that's truly sophisticated.

Seasonal Flavors

Check out our Instagram Page to see the Flavors of the Month!

American Apple Pie Ice Cream
American Apple Pie


This mouthwatering creation swirls rich caramel sauce with crunchy graham cracks and authentic waffle cone pieces, capturing the essence of a classic American dessert in every scoop. Perfect for celebrating summer and savoring the taste of tradition!

Honey Lavender (GF)


Delight in the soothing flavor of Honey Lavender Dream! This elegant ice cream blends the floral notes of lavender with the natural sweetness of honey, creating a creamy and calming treat that's perfect for a moment of indulgence.

Smoreo ice cream
S'Moreo


This delectable ice cream mixes the classic charm of s’mores with the beloved crunch of Oreos. Dive into smooth, marshmallow-infused ice cream, swirled with chunks of graham cracker and rich chocolate chunks. It’s the ultimate campfire delight, no flames required!

Blueberry (DF/GF/V)


Indulge in the rich, fruity flavor of Blueberry Bliss Ice Cream! Every scoop is packed with sweet, juicy blueberries, creating a creamy, berry-filled delight that's perfect for any occasion.

shakes

Rocky Road Shake
I-15 Pothole Explosion Shake


Dive into decadence with our I-15 Pothole "Rocky Road" Explosion shake. This rich and creamy shake blends velvety chocolate ice cream with chunks of marshmallow, crunchy almonds, and a swirl of chocolate syrup. It's a delicious adventure in every sip!

Mint Chip Shake


Refresh your taste buds with our Mint Chip Shake! This cool and creamy treat blends smooth mint ice cream with crunchy chocolate chips, creating a perfectly balanced, refreshing, and indulgent shake.

Cookie Dough Overload

Dive into a journal of indulgence with a towering blend of rich vanilla ice cream and generous chunks of soft, chewy cookie dough. Drizzled with warm chocolate syrup and crowned with a mountain of whipped cream and full-size cookies on top.

Come visit us!

Syracuse, Utah
Thurgood Creamery

Syracuse West Town Center
2432 West 1700 South B1
Syracuse, UT

385-442-9996

hello@thurgoodcreamery.com

Ice cream flavors - Thurgood Creamery